{
  "schema": "https://cyberdelic.space/schemas/tending-audit-v1.json",
  "audit_id": "TEND-2026-10-24",
  "run_type": "scheduled-tending",
  "started_at": "2026-10-24T14:10:53Z",
  "completed_at": "2026-10-24T16:04:02Z",
  "timezone": "America/Vancouver",
  "office_versions": {"cartographer": "0.1", "gardener": "0.1", "librarian": "0.1"},
  "authority": "OFFICE-PUBLICATION-AUTHORITY version 1.1; publication is distinct from ratification.",
  "repository": {
    "branch": "codex/tending-2026-10-24",
    "starting_commit": "4be90a18628fca4ec3b3e5606f5aff02bb71b76b",
    "preflight": "Clean website checkout matched fetched origin/main. Sibling reader source and unrelated untracked FN-45 metadata are left untouched. Private correspondence and Agent Comms are excluded.",
    "publication_action": "Local validation passed for pull-request publication of a semantic no-op. Require hosting success before merge and production verification afterward. This pre-merge audit does not claim deployment."
  },
  "cartographer": {
    "state": "retained-existing-proposals",
    "inbox_items": 0,
    "outward_search_performed": true,
    "declared_question": "How can a system make cross-perspective usefulness visible without treating agreement as truth or majority rule?",
    "inquiry_basis": "Existing Community Notes proposals REL-P-000012, REL-P-000013, and REL-P-000014, and exact FN-14 and FN-25.",
    "sources_checked": [{
      "urls": ["https://communitynotes.x.com/guide/en/about/introduction", "https://communitynotes.x.com/guide/en/contributing/diversity-of-perspectives", "https://communitynotes.x.com/guide/en/under-the-hood/ranking-notes"],
      "public_source_repository": "https://github.com/twitter/communitynotes",
      "source_revision": "93647eb9ad57642c05a9dc79fba9d6df42c5ae06",
      "source_paths": ["documentation/about/introduction.md", "documentation/contributing/diversity-of-perspectives.md", "documentation/under-the-hood/ranking-notes.md"],
      "attribution": "Community Notes maintainers, official public introduction, diversity documentation, and ranking documentation.",
      "checked_at": "2026-10-24",
      "source_facts": ["The introduction describes contributor-written and rated context, requiring agreement across differing prior ratings rather than simple majority rule.", "The diversity guide says rating perspectives are inferred from prior note ratings, not demographic labels, follows, or posts. It separately describes graph-based quality analyses that do not directly determine individual note ratings.", "The ranking documentation describes a single global helpfulness score rather than personalized note scores, with safeguards and evolving status rules."],
      "inference": "Cross-perspective helpfulness remains a useful replaceable technical reference for FN-14 and a contrast to FN-25's richer durable artifacts, explicit dissent, and unresolved questions. Helpfulness is not a truth certificate or a complete representation of disagreement.",
      "uncertainty": "Documentation comparison only, not a participant trial, independent efficacy evaluation, scoring-code execution, or assessment of every current safeguard. No endorsement, partnership, or collaboration is implied.",
      "access_note": "The web reader returned empty extracted bodies for the guide pages. Their official public Markdown sources were read through the existing repository instead. The introduction and diversity guide were read in full, and the ranking overview, matrix-factorization explanation, and agreement safeguards were read for this bounded question. No contributor dataset or private material was ingested."
    }],
    "candidates_created": [],
    "no_proposal_reason": "The existing proposal family already records the useful connection and the distinction between global helpfulness, truth, and multi-perspective inquiry. Another node or edge would duplicate it. Today's checked date remains in this audit without replacing historical source checks.",
    "handoff": "Existing Community Notes proposals and today's source-fact/inference comparison handed to the Gardener."
  },
  "gardener": {
    "state": "reviewed-no-relational-change",
    "reviewed": ["Current 12-node, 7-edge manifest and Community Notes proposal family", "Complete exact FN-14 and FN-25 sections, A-001, BN-005, and I-003, plus the Kernel's verbs and laws", "Focused summaries, themes, related paths, evidence, and the same-run Cartographer output"],
    "changes": [],
    "retained_decisions": ["Keep cross-perspective helpfulness distinct from proof of truth or a representation of every perspective.", "Keep inferred rating patterns distinct from identity, demographics, or the full structure of disagreement.", "Keep FN-25's explicit dissent, provenance, and unresolved questions visible beyond a note's helpfulness status.", "Keep technical adjacency model-proposed and exact historical office publications separate from the active publication authority.", "Keep the three-item Attending selection and every historical audit intact."],
    "decision_reason": "The focused cross-form comparison found existing metadata and caveats adequate. No relation, lifecycle, evidence, or placement repair was warranted. No relational-change essay or selection rotation is needed. This bounded semantic reading does not imply a fresh reading of every exact publication."
  },
  "librarian": {
    "state": "reviewed-no-catalog-change",
    "records_created": [],
    "records_revised": [],
    "records_removed": [],
    "catalog_count_before": 35,
    "catalog_count_after": 35,
    "records_examined": ["All 35 cumulative catalog records", "Current relational manifest, same-run Cartographer and Gardener outputs, and focused exact evidence for FN-14, FN-25, A-001, BN-005, I-003, and the Kernel"],
    "decision_reason": "Existing ordinary-language routes for people who disagree, context notes, cross-perspective helpfulness, open software organs, and public conversation remain supported and useful. Retain every record and prior tending date without a date-only refresh. External neighbours remain proposed. The Librarian performed no outward search."
  },
  "public_summary": [
    "Cartographer: Rechecked Community Notes through its official public documentation. Its existing cross-perspective connection remains useful; no duplicate proposal was added.",
    "Gardener: Compared exact notes, office instruments, the press artifact, and Kernel passages. Helpfulness stays distinct from truth; no relational repair was needed.",
    "Librarian: Existing search terms remain useful. All 35 catalog records and their earlier tending dates stay unchanged.",
    "Care: Exact works, photographs, recordings, graph claims, history, and the three-item selection remain intact. No relational essay or selection rotation was manufactured.",
    "Checks: 93 tests, four-width browser checks, retained discovery routes, exact-source hashes, links, all 63 recordings, and the complete multipart mirror passed locally.",
    "Outcome: Valid no-change review. Only the audit, daily journal, and mirror are updated; production verification follows deployment, not this audit."
  ],
  "validation": {
    "state": "passed",
    "checks": [
      "82 reader/server/mirror/journal tests and 11 playback tests passed",
      "Browser regression passed at 320, 390, 768, and 1280 pixels, with three themes, keyboard discovery, proposed labels, three-work results, six-result search, no-JavaScript archive, future-catalog fixture, missing-catalog fallback, and no page errors",
      "Focused checks preserve people-who-disagree, context-notes, software-organs, Studio, and portable-bytecode searches, plus the proposed Community Notes three-work constellation and its qualified related paths; the six-bullet journal, 63-date seven-page archive, and unchanged three-item selection fit at 320 pixels",
      "JSON/XML, 47 indexed source/image SHA-256 values and lengths, 4689 internal references, JavaScript syntax, and every catalog evidence locator passed",
      "Narration and complete multipart mirror checks preserve 63 Lewis recordings, 465.0 minutes, 319.4 MiB, and all 18 audio parts",
      "All 11 transaction paths match active governance; all 340 protected publication/audio/relation/history files remain unchanged, including all 35 catalog records and prior tending dates",
      "Exact publications, photographs, audio, graph, proposals, inbox, governance, historical audits, global indexes, sitemap, and selection outside its journal remain unchanged; sibling source and unrelated FN-45 metadata preserve their preflight state",
      "October 11, 12, and 21 remain blocked in the journal; no historical audit is relabelled by later publication"
    ],
    "preview_url": "http://127.0.0.1:8787/",
    "production_verification": "Not claimed by this pre-merge audit. Require hosting success, exact public bytes and digests, and production browser regression after merge."
  },
  "files_changed": ["living-relations/audits/2026-10-24.json", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/index.html", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/index.json", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/index.html", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/page-2.html", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/page-3.html", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/page-4.html", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/page-5.html", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/page-6.html", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/page-7.html", "cyberdelic-space.zip"],
  "public_change": false,
  "operational_journal_updated": true,
  "relational_field_changed": false,
  "relational_essay_created": false,
  "valid_no_op": true,
  "run_state": "validated-for-publication",
  "historical_runs_rewritten": false,
  "scheduled_configuration_changed": false
}
