{
  "schema": "https://cyberdelic.space/schemas/tending-audit-v1.json",
  "audit_id": "TEND-2026-10-19",
  "run_type": "scheduled-tending",
  "started_at": "2026-10-19T14:14:59Z",
  "completed_at": "2026-10-19T15:31:03Z",
  "timezone": "America/Vancouver",
  "office_versions": {"cartographer": "0.1", "gardener": "0.1", "librarian": "0.1"},
  "authority": "OFFICE-PUBLICATION-AUTHORITY version 1.1; publication is distinct from ratification.",
  "repository": {
    "branch": "codex/tending-2026-10-19",
    "starting_commit": "895db089a1866524a57b24e7a6f8cc2f33307660",
    "preflight": "Clean website checkout matched fetched origin/main. Reader source and unrelated untracked FN-45 metadata were left untouched. Private correspondence and Agent Comms were excluded.",
    "publication_action": "Validated for pull-request publication. Production verification follows merge and is reported separately; this audit does not claim a future deployment."
  },
  "cartographer": {
    "state": "retained-existing-proposals",
    "inbox_items": 0,
    "outward_search_performed": true,
    "declared_question": "Which execution assumptions belong inside a generative plate, and which should remain replaceable properties of a reader?",
    "inquiry_basis": "Existing WebAssembly proposals REL-P-000010 and REL-P-000011 and exact FN-33.",
    "sources_checked": [{
      "url": "https://www.w3.org/TR/wasm-core-2/",
      "attribution": "W3C WebAssembly Core Specification, sections Scope, Security Considerations, and Embedding.",
      "checked_at": "2026-10-19",
      "source_facts": ["The core defines computational semantics but leaves environment-specific invocation and interaction to embedding interfaces.", "Environmental capabilities are supplied through imported functions controlled by the embedder.", "The embedding interface connects the host to the defined semantics."],
      "inference": "The portable-module precedent remains relevant to FN-33, but executing instructions is not the same as preserving an artwork's full encounter, assets, or authorized edition lineage.",
      "uncertainty": "Focused primary-document review only, not a module execution, browser interoperability test, security assessment, or claim about the entire specification. No endorsement or architectural equivalence is implied."
    }],
    "access_note": "A guessed split introduction path returned 404, while the canonical document exceeded the web reader's size limit. A direct read of the canonical W3C document succeeded; relevant scope, security, and embedding passages were extracted. Failed reads were not evidence and no failed candidate was published.",
    "candidates_created": [],
    "no_proposal_reason": "The existing proposal pair already states the portable-computation and replaceable-host distinction with explicit artistic and lineage limits. No duplicate node or edge was needed.",
    "handoff": "Existing WebAssembly queue and focused source comparison handed to the Gardener."
  },
  "gardener": {
    "state": "recommended-one-catalog-clarification",
    "reviewed": ["Current 12-node, 7-edge manifest and WebAssembly proposal pair", "Exact FN-33, I-005, BN-006, A-005, BN-005, I-003, and the Kernel's verbs and laws", "Catalog descriptions and related paths across portability, execution boundaries, and Dear Elsewhere's public prototype records"],
    "changes": [{
      "target": "catalog:cyberdelic-os:a-005",
      "path": "living-relations/catalog.json",
      "decision": "Make the public artifact record's browser dependency and external-source limits visible in catalog context.",
      "evidence": [{"source": "living-content/cyberdelic-os/a-005/v000001.md", "locator": "A compatible browser is still needed to perform the viewer, and external links may stop resolving.; They do not establish identity, rights, consent, or unbroken availability."}],
      "confidence": "strong",
      "rationale": "The portable-export description is accurate, but this record lacked an explicit uncertainty field. Its own Keeping the work section gives concrete limits a reader should encounter beside the export promise. This clarifies metadata without changing source, attribution, lifecycle, or relation claims."
    }],
    "retained_decisions": ["Keep portable computation distinct from a complete visual or media encounter.", "Keep included file bytes distinct from external references and browser capabilities.", "Keep the dated prototype record distinct from a current runtime audit or completed interpersonal study.", "Keep graph, review states, ratification history, and the finite selection unchanged."],
    "decision_reason": "One source-grounded context clarification was warranted. No graph repair, lifecycle change, or relational-change essay was needed. The review was bounded and does not claim full semantic inspection of every publication."
  },
  "librarian": {
    "state": "revised-one-catalog-record",
    "records_created": [],
    "records_revised": ["catalog:cyberdelic-os:a-005"],
    "records_removed": [],
    "catalog_count_before": 34,
    "catalog_count_after": 34,
    "decision_reason": "Read all 34 cumulative records and the same-run office outputs. Applied the Gardener's clarification to A-005, adding exact evidence, dated uncertainty, and two ordinary-language terms: compatible browser and external links may disappear. Existing title, summary, subjects, questions, related path, and model-proposed status remain unchanged. All 33 other records are retained. The Librarian performed no outward search."
  },
  "public_summary": [
    "Cartographer: Rechecked WebAssembly's host boundary against the existing question. Existing proposals suffice; no new neighbour or edge was added.",
    "Gardener: Found a useful catalog clarification: Dear Elsewhere's portable viewer still needs a compatible browser, and external links can disappear.",
    "Librarian: Added that record's documented limits, exact evidence, and two search phrases. All 34 records remain; none was added or removed.",
    "Care: Exact works, photographs, audio, earlier audits, graph claims, and the three-item selection remain intact. No relational essay was manufactured.",
    "Checks: 93 tests, four-width browser checks, both new search phrases, source hashes, links, all 63 recordings, and the complete multipart mirror passed.",
    "Outcome: One catalog context improvement passed publication checks. No new relationship or ratification was made; deployment is verified separately after merge."
  ],
  "validation": {
    "state": "passed",
    "checks": [
      "82 reader/server/mirror/journal tests and 11 playback tests passed",
      "Browser regression passed at 320, 390, 768, and 1280 pixels, three themes, keyboard discovery, proposed labels, three-work results, six-result search, no-JavaScript archive, future-catalog fixture, and missing-catalog fallback",
      "Both new search phrases find A-005; its expanded constellation context shows the browser dependency and dated uncertainty; the artifact reader fits at 320 pixels; the latest journal has six bullets and the selection remains three items",
      "JSON/XML, 47 indexed source and image SHA-256 values and lengths, 4662 internal references, JavaScript syntax, and every catalog evidence locator passed",
      "Narration and complete multipart mirror validation preserve 63 Lewis recordings, 465.0 minutes, 319.4 MiB, and all 18 offline audio parts",
      "All 11 changed paths match active governance; all 334 protected source/audio/relation/history files and 33 other catalog records remain unchanged",
      "A-005's existing title, summary, subjects, questions, related path, confidence, and proposal state are unchanged; public indexes, sitemap, exact publications, photographs, audio, graph, proposals, governance, historical audits, and the Attending selection outside its journal remain unchanged",
      "The sibling reader source and unrelated FN-45 metadata retain their earlier state"
    ],
    "preview_url": "http://127.0.0.1:8787/",
    "production_verification": "Not claimed by this pre-merge audit. Verify changed public URLs, exact-source digests, and production behavior after deployment."
  },
  "files_changed": ["living-relations/catalog.json", "living-relations/audits/2026-10-19.json", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/index.html", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/index.json", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/index.html", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/page-2.html", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/page-3.html", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/page-4.html", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/page-5.html", "project/cyberdelic-os/attending/journal/page-6.html", "cyberdelic-space.zip"],
  "public_change": true,
  "relational_field_changed": false,
  "relational_essay_created": false,
  "valid_no_op": false,
  "run_state": "validated-for-publication",
  "historical_runs_rewritten": false,
  "scheduled_configuration_changed": false
}
